Chapter 8 Chapter 8 Two Different Reasonings

Meow!The kitten came out of nowhere in the dark corner of the room, walked lazily through the living room, and looked around.The kitten has lost the bloody and ferocious eyes at night, and has become extremely gentle and cute. It crawled out of the kitchen window. Zhao Jian was worried that it would fall to its death and turn into a ghost, because it was often written like this in novels.He poked his head out to look, and the kitten stopped by another window, and looked back at Zhao Jian, as if smiling. At about ten o'clock, Zhao Jian received a call from Han Tieshan, the writer of mystery novels. He said he had found some information and asked Zhao Jian to come and have a look. data of.

Zhao Jian excitedly rushed to the private room of a teahouse. Han Tieshan handed several documents to Zhao Jian and said: "I spent a whole day searching and analyzing this yesterday. You should take a look at the first document first. Very relevant." related to me?Zhao Jian was at a loss as to what he could be involved in this case. He read it carefully with a feeling of resistance, and there was a hospital certificate attached to the back of the document. After reading the hospital certificate, he fell deeply into those words, and turned his head to look at Han Tieshan in surprise.

Han Tieshan did not wait for Zhao Jian to ask questions before answering him: "This is the conclusion I got from the hospital by comparing the data of Mo Xiaoyi's pregnancy test with the data of the deceased Yu Kuang. I have asked several doctors and their opinions are Similarly, the child in Mo Xiaoyi's womb does not belong to her boyfriend Yu Kuang." Zhao Jian's eyes radiated a kind of fear, and he said nervously: "No, Mo Xiaoyi will not be the murderer." This sentence is a bit jumpy, but it is also a logical reaction in reason. Han Tieshan went to find out that the child in Mo Xiaoyi's belly was not Yu Kuang's, that is, he suspected that Mo Xiaoyi was the murderer, so Zhao Jianli immediately objected.Of course, Zhao Jian never thought about the question of Mo Xiaoyi being the murderer. He went to track down the murderer for Mo Xiaoyi's sake. If Mo Xiaoyi was the murderer, what's the point of doing so?

Han Tieshan took a sip of tea, avoided Zhao Jian's excitement, and said tactfully: "Don't be afraid, I didn't say that Mo Xiaoyi was the murderer, I just showed you the information. Yu Kuang was the only deceased who was related. When Sun Lin's father was murdered, she was already locked up in the police station. Logically speaking, she had no time to commit the crime. However, the method of poisoning was used, so it is uncertain whether she committed the crime. Time, basically the suspicion is not big. Besides, you have been taking care of Mo Xiaoyi these days. The murderer recently killed the fourth victim, Wu Meimei, with extremely cruel means, which requires a lot of free time and tools for committing the crime. Mo Xiaoyi probably does not have it. .”

Zhao Jian nodded in agreement, and couldn't wait to read the second document. Han Tieshan said on the sidelines: "Sun Lin's father's wife, Shen Xuemei, and her husband, Sun Lin's father, had a broken relationship a few years ago. They quarreled for a long time and got divorced. He did not divorce. The deceased Sun Lin’s father probably did not divorce his wife because of his own assets. He is the boss of a large company and has been with many women in recent years, including employees of his own company. If Shen Xuemei committed murder In terms of motivation, it may be for the huge amount of property, or to leave Sun Lin's father. She has enough reasons to kill Sun Lin's father. However, it is said that after Sun Lin's father died, she did not ask about the company's affairs, including finances. It seems that she is not interested in money. And she has no connection with the other dead, but she has enough time and space to commit crimes. However, her education is very low, she graduated from high school, and she doesn't seem to read much in daily life. It’s deserted, and I probably don’t know so many mystery novels.”

"That means she's not too suspicious." "Yes, according to the current information, this is the case. As for Xu Ying, the mistress at the scene of Sun Lin's father's death, I have met this woman several times. She was a model before. She is the wife of the writer Ye Luo. Ye Luo is more beautiful than her. Fifteen years older. This woman may have had an affair because of Ye Luo's lack of ability. It seems that Ye Luo happened to be on a business trip these days. There is a very coincidental thing, this woman was in the same house as Wu Meimei who was just killed Model company, and the relationship is extremely bad. It is said that Xu Ying's resignation was murdered by Wu Meimei. This woman is related to the two deceased, and has not yet found any connection with the deceased Yu Kuang, and she has plenty of time to commit crimes. High school, however, is not deserted, it can be regarded as a white-collar class, and the suspicion is the biggest among these few people."

Looking at Xu Ying in the profile photo, Zhao Jian couldn't help asking: "Could it be her?" "It's just that the suspicion is a bit bigger, and further investigation by the police is needed. There are also a few people, such as Han Dawei and Ye Luo, the bosses of Feitian Model Company. Han Dawei and the third deceased, Sun Lin's father, also knew each other. They are correspondingly suspected and have motives for killing. For example, you can kill Yu Kuang for love and to get Mo Xiaoyi. The writer Ye Luo may also kill Sun Lin’s father after discovering an extramarital affair, and he is also a writer of suspense mystery novels, which is most suitable, and he Going on a business trip at this time has to make people suspicious. Look at the last document. According to inference, Ye Luo is the most suspected. He can plan to kill his former enemy Wu Meimei for his wife Xu Ying. However, I Personally, the suspect is not necessarily the murderer."

Zhao Jian asked suspiciously: "Then is there someone else who is the murderer?" Han Tieshan said firmly: "No, it must be these people who are related to the deceased." "Then who do you think it will be?" Han Tieshan asked back, "Why do you think it's Xu Ying?" "From these materials, the first deceased was a servant. Except for Mo Xiaoyi, all these people are capable of hiring them. As far as the conditions for committing the crime are concerned, these people also have the ability to have the greatest connection with the four deceased. Xu Ying and her husband writer Ye Luo are the most likely suspects. Ye Luo is the most likely because he is a writer of mystery novels, so he can conceive an elaborate murder plan, but you said You knew that Ye Luo would not do that, so you ruled it out, leaving his wife Xu Ying, you said that the murderer and the deceased must have internal and external connections."

"Theoretically, this is the case. To be honest, I felt the same as you at first. Among these people, I also thought it was Xu Ying. In mystery novels, people who are often invisible are murderers. The murderer is good at disguising." Yes. However, this is only a rough analysis on the surface. It is really necessary to prove whether it is the murderer, to find out where the crime happened, and to find the killing tools or related evidence. But we are not law enforcement officers, so it is difficult to further investigate. I It’s just a novel, and the real solution to the case is to find the police.”

Zhao Jian looked at the information in his hand and said embarrassingly, "I'm sorry to trouble you, but I also understand that your ability is limited." "Do your best. By the way, I'm going to sign elsewhere tomorrow, so I can only help you here for the time being." "Oh, then please do me one last favor. Let's go to the police station and tell them about our analysis so that they can investigate this Xu Ying further." Seeing that the young man was so stubborn, Han Tieshan had no choice but to agree.He himself understood that writing a book and solving a case were two different things, as if what he said was far from what was actually possible.

The two went straight to the criminal police team after they left the teahouse. At this time, Liu Tianming was looking at the materials of the case, and at the same time listening to the contents of the books that his colleagues who had finished reading mystery novels told him. He had already listened to seven or eight books, and this method really worked. A colleague sat next to him and talked about Stephen King's "Bag of Bones". He wondered if Liu Tianming was listening carefully. "Mike was a sensitive, middle-aged writer past his prime and in a state of depleted inspiration. Tragically, his beloved wife died unexpectedly in a car accident and he was informed by the coroner that his His wife was pregnant, but his wife never told him, and after he investigated and learned that his wife had quietly gone to their villa far away by the sea many times, he decided to go to the villa to solve the mystery in his heart. "When he arrived at the villa in the middle of the night on the first day, he heard the cry of the child, smelled the smell of carrion, and the letter magnets on the refrigerator often formed strange phrases automatically, leading him to explore the strange behavior of his wife before she died. .His wife has collected many newspaper clippings and photos from the last century in the basement, all about Sarah, a black female singer who was once popular in the local area and then disappeared mysteriously." "Writer?" Liu Tianming listened to the writer in "Bag of Bones", and immediately found the information of Xu Ying's husband, Ye Luo. It's an imitation of mystery novels again. Who can be so familiar with mystery novels?Can it imitate the content of mystery novels?Except for fans of mystery novels, there are only writers.Could the murderer be a crazy book fan?Book fans are hard to find, anyone who buys mystery novels to read is a book fan, and there are only a few writers. What's more, by coincidence, the husband of Xu Ying, the person at the scene of the crime, happened to be a writer of mystery novels, and this Ye Luo never appeared.I have been married twice before, can I rest assured that I married such a beautiful woman? This "Bag of Bones" indirectly reminded him that this Ye Luo might have the idea of ​​killing because his inspiration was exhausted and he found out that his wife was having an affair with someone else.Some writers are very perverted. They go to experience killing to find their feelings. There seem to be such writers in foreign countries. I was exhausted looking for inspiration, and found out that my wife was stealing, so I devised a shocking murder plan? He sent someone to check on Ye Luo. It was revealed that Ye Luo's book had been plagiarized and imitated other people's novels, and there were indeed imitations of other people's novels. Although the text was different, the plot of the story was the same. Luo knows how to imitate other people's novels. "Many writers now plagiarize, relying on fame to hype, it's normal." "How is the relationship between Ye Luo and his wife Xu Ying?" "It is said that Ye Luo dotes on his sweet wife very much, and the marriage relationship is good. It is natural to feel pity for marrying a beautiful woman who is more than ten years younger than himself." Assuming that Ye Luo is the murderer, he is playing a killing game, the purpose is to bring inspiration to the novel, it is very likely that he will find out that his wife has a secret meeting with others, and he did not attack his wife because of pity, and teach her a lesson. The wife who was handcuffed to the bedside repented, and Ye Luo could also make his wife dare not have an affair in the future.However, this is only a hypothesis, a conjecture based on the combination of all data. Liu Tianming was thinking about it when someone knocked on the door and came in. "Captain, there is a writer and a young man who say they have a lead on the case." Liu Tianming was taken aback, writer?Could it be Ye Luo, say Cao Cao, Cao Cao will arrive?However, none of the two people who came in looked like the person in the photo in the file he was holding. These two people showed their identities, one was the writer Han Tieshan, and the other was Mo Xiaoyi's friend. Liu Tianming glanced at Zhao Jian, and asked suspiciously, "Where did we seem to meet?" "Maybe I've seen it before. Last time I came here to pick up Mo Xiaoyi." Zhao Jian was a little uncomfortable being watched by Liu Tianming, so he smiled awkwardly. In fact, he knew in his heart that they had looked at each other in the park that day. "Then what clues do you have?" It's very strange, how did a well-known reasoning writer Han Tieshan get involved in this serial murder case, and the friend of the deceased's girlfriend, what are these two mismatched people doing? "It's like this. This young man asked me for help. I helped him find some information about the case and analyzed it. I want to talk to your police. I hope your police can investigate." Han Tieshan said calmly. "Information? Tell me." Han Tieshan gestured to Zhao Jian with his eyes, and asked Zhao Jian to speak by himself. "Mr. Han and I both believe that the murderer and the deceased must have an internal relationship. They are definitely not the kind of mental patients who take pleasure in imitating killing. These are the information we have found. From the people who have a relationship with the deceased, this is called Xu Ying's woman is the most suspected, she is related to the deceased Sun Lin's father and Wu Meimei, and she used to work in the same model company as Wu Meimei, so the relationship is extremely bad, and she also has the conditions to commit the crime." Zhao Jian handed the information to Liu dawn. "We have already understood the situation you found, but how can we conclude that Xu Ying is the most suspected person based on this alone? Many people have colleagues with bad relations, and even fought, but we haven't seen them either. Murder? The murderer is an extremely cunning person. This woman only has a high school education. Also, why did she kill the lover she just met? Have you thought about this? If you infer this way, Ye Luo is even more suspicious. "Liu Tian said obviously very unhappy. "but……" "No need, but let me ask you, why are you investigating this case?" Liu Tianming asked. "To find out the real culprit, help Mo Xiaoyi." "That means you are doing it for a girl. Let me tell you, this is a matter for the police, not your affair." Liu Tianming roared in a rough voice. Han Tieshan on the side said with embarrassment: "We are just providing information, and we hope you can check it out. As for Ye Luo, I know him better, and he probably wouldn't do such a thing." Liu Tianming looked at Han Tieshan. After all, he was a well-known writer, so he couldn't give others any embarrassment. Instead, he smiled and said, "Okay, I will consider it, thank you!" After seeing off these two outrageous people, Liu Tian was obviously very depressed. Looking at the information on the table, they thought it was Xu Ying, but it was somewhat close to his own idea. He suspected it was Ye Luo. There are many inexplicable people and things in life, making it unbelievable. No matter what, since Xu Ying and Ye Luo were suspected, Liu Tianming decided to take someone to search Xu Ying and Ye Luo's residence, and ask some things again by the way , a sudden attack or something like that, if the other party is the murderer, they may be caught off guard, at least they can find some clues. As a result, there were no unexpected gains, and the villa was very peaceful.Xu Ying was watching TV at home. When she saw Liu Tianming and the criminal police, she looked a little unhappy, but she still accepted the questioning very cooperatively. "Where were you on the night of the 18th?" This is the time when the murderer poisoned the second victim, Yu Kuang's home, on the night of June 18th. "Of course I sleep at home at night. Since my husband went on a business trip a few days ago, I haven't dared to go out at night. Now the security is not good." This answer is the same as the previous statement. "So, is there any proof that you're home?" Xu Ying said a little angrily: "How do you find someone to prove it when you are sleeping at home? Didn't you ask me last time? Why are you police so annoying? I only do it once!" once?Liu Tianming smiled secretly. It seemed that this woman was very afraid that the news of her affair with others would be spread, and she was worried that her husband would come back to deal with her. Maybe she also had an affair with the deceased Sun Lin's father that night.However, Liu Tianming specifically mentioned: "Then, when the other deceased Sun Lin's father died, you were together?" Hearing this, the woman in front of her lowered her expression and tone, nodded and said, "I just met him." "We know this, so, where were you from eight to twelve yesterday morning?" This was the death time of the fourth deceased. "I was at home yesterday morning, and then I drove to the housekeeping in the south of the city to pick up a waiter for cleaning. I told her what to do and what to do at home. After I finished, I sent her back. It was almost twelve o'clock. , I found a meal at a restaurant on the way back." "You mean you were home all that time?" "That's right, you don't suspect that I'm the murderer, do you? Then go and investigate." "It's not a suspicion. We're just a matter of routine. Do you have the contact information of that domestic service company? Provide us with it." Xu Ying rummaged through her purse dissatisfied, took out a business card from the small pocket of the purse, handed it to Liu Tianming and said, "I only have one, write down the address and return it to me." Liu Tianming recorded the address and phone number. In order to ease the atmosphere, he then stood up and walked around. When he passed the desks and cabinets, he carefully checked whether there were ceramic toys of Indian villains on them, because there were An obvious plot is that there are ten little Indian china figurines on the table, and for every person who dies, there will be one less little porcelain figurine. He thought that the murderer might also imitate this plot. Among the messy gadgets, he didn't find any decorations similar to Indian villains. He turned around and walked to the bookshelf again, looked at the books, but there was still no clue of his interest. He turned back and asked Xu Ying who was sitting on the sofa: "Where did your husband, Mr. Ye Luo go?" "I remember I said it last time. He went to Yunnan. He said it was because a novel needed to be inspected in Yunnan, and he would come back in ten days." There was still great dissatisfaction in his tone. "What date did you leave?" "No. 13." "Oh, what novel has your husband written lately?" "I don't know, I never read his novels." "why?" "There is no reason. If you see that person eating and drinking every day, what's so good about the things he wrote, isn't it just the horror and intimidation, I might as well go to the movies." "Can you give me his phone number?" Xu Ying was taken aback, and Liu Tianming immediately explained: "We won't tell about that matter, don't worry, we just want to know about other things." "Okay, just remember, 1585700****." Liu Tianming pressed the dial button on his mobile phone and listened to the receiver quietly. After a while, he heard: "Sorry, the number you dialed is not in the service area." Xu Ying wanted to say something, but stopped, and waited for Liu Tianming to put down the phone before she said: "We have agreed, we can't tell my husband about this, otherwise, you will destroy other people's marriage on purpose, I will I will take you to court." "Don't worry, it won't happen." Liu Tianming said in his heart that the pressure of the case is enough, there is no need to mess with rich people like you, and if he is complained again, his job will not be guaranteed. The people from the criminal police team checked briefly, but found nothing, so Liu Tianming sent someone to the housekeeping service company in the south of the city to check what Xu Ying said, and then said very politely: "Sorry to bother you." He led the team away up. After returning to the police station, Liu Tianming asked people to go to the airline and the train station to check whether Ye Luo really went to Yunnan. He suspected that Ye Luo had not left the city, but just used Yunnan as a cover, lurking like a devil . Not long after, the person who went to investigate the housekeeping service company came back and reported: "Xu Ying did go to that housekeeping service company yesterday, and the staff also confirmed that she registered at Chengnan Housekeeping Service Company at 9:10 in the morning and picked up the housekeeper Her house took about 50 minutes on the way, and according to the waiter’s description, she didn’t get off the bus halfway. Then, when she arrived at the villa, the waiter was with her all the time, and Xu Ying stared at her to work. However, she left for more than ten minutes on the way, and then Wait until she finishes her work and send her back to the domestic service company. It’s almost twelve o’clock. This is the confession, and the waitress also brought it.” Liu Tianming looked at the record and said, "Call the waitress in." A woman walked in with her head down, obviously a little scared, after all, it was a police station. Seeing her timid expression, Liu Tianming asked gently: "I just ask you a few questions, and you can go back. It's no big deal. By the way, when did the elder sister start working in this housekeeping service company?" " "I have only been here for less than a month. I used to work in other places. Now that the economy is not good, I come to a big city and work more." "Oh, since that woman named Xu Ying picked you up yesterday, has she ever left?" "Yes, just go away for a while, about ten minutes. She watched me work, as if she was afraid that I would be lazy and damage her house, but she was very polite." Liu Tianming said in his heart that the woman looked timid. , quite able to say, asked: "Are you really sure?" "Well, I remember what happened yesterday." "Okay, it's okay, let's go." Liu Tianming thought that it would be impossible to commit a crime in ten minutes. It would take at least fifty minutes to drive from Xu Ying's house in the north of the city to the south of the city. It would be useless to drive a speeding car. With so many traffic lights, In addition, they have to kill people and put them in the park, unless it is Superman, it seems that Xu Ying has no possibility of killing people. Liu Tianming then thought again, if the murderer was the writer Ye Luo, would Xu Ying assist him?However, this woman should not help her husband to kill the lover she just met. It is not necessary logically, unless it is to complete the imitation of nursery rhymes in novels, deliberately let her wife go to Lieyan, and thus kill Lieyan Or, the nursery rhyme "eight little Indian boys went hunting in Devon; one died and died, and only seven remained of the eight". This seems like an outrageous idea, somewhat fictionalized.Liu Tianming smiled wryly to himself, and instead scolded Zhao Jian and the writer Han Tieshan for making trouble for him. Now that it's all over, everyone has checked and there is evidence of alibi. As for Xu Ying's husband, the writer Ye Luo, as Liu Tianming expected, there was no information on the airline that he was going to Yunnan on the 13th.Comparing the videos at the train station and the bus station, there is no one who looks like Ye Luo on the train to Yunnan, which means that the mystery writer Ye Luo has not left the city. Since Ye Luo hadn't left, where would he be?Is he the murderer?If he wasn't the murderer, why didn't he leave the city? Another purpose of Liu Tianming's surprise attack on Xu Ying and Ye Luo's house this time is to extract Ye Luo's DNA in the villa and compare it with the semen in Wu Meimei's body to see if it is Ye Luo's. Sure enough, a new discovery was made. The DNA of Wu Meimei's semen was the same as the DNA of the only male sampled from Xu Ying's villa. There are a total of three people's DNA in the villa sample, two are female and one is male, which means that there are three people living in the villa, two women and one man.That man must be Ye Luo, one of the women is Xu Ying, what about the other? Liu Tianming thought of the maid in the murderer's first murder blog post, that is, the first deceased, indicating that this maid was still in the villa not long ago, but she has not seen or mentioned it since the incident, it is very likely Another woman in the sample was the first deceased. Since the semen in Wu Meimei's body belonged to Ye Luo, then this case must be directly related to Ye Luo, and Ye Luo might be the murderer. Liu Tianming was a little puzzled. If Ye Luo was the murderer, what about Xu Ying?The dead are all related to her, is she also the murderer?But she has evidence that the fourth deceased was not present when she was killed. Could it be that two people committed the crime together?Or Xu Ying didn't know, but Ye Luo was planning to kill her around her.