Chapter 56 Pleading for her father, the female head nurse angrily sued the hospital where she worked

Earlier, I mentioned a female head nurse from Beidaihe Hospital, Sister Shen Shuping, many times. So why does this sister Shen often come to Beijing to look for me?Speaking of which, there is also an eye-catching civil claim case triggered by a medical dispute.This is not an ordinary medical malpractice case. It is said to be unusual because there is a unique particularity behind this case.As ordinary consumers, we see a lot of news about patients filing medical lawsuits with hospitals for various reasons in our daily life. In the end, it is rare to be put to death by the relevant personnel of the own hospital; another peculiarity of this case is that it was not someone else who caused the death of the father, but the hospital. Shen Shuping, the daughter of the deceased who worked for 32 years and served as the head nurse for 13 years.It is the first case in the country that medical personnel have made many mistakes in the hospital they work in, and finally brought it to court.Because of the particularity of this case, it not only aroused great attention from the local people at the beginning, but also attracted widespread attention from all walks of life across the country.

On the morning of September 13, 1999, 76-year-old Shen Ming, the old leader and one of the founders of Beidaihe District People's Hospital, was admitted to the Department of Internal Medicine of Beidaihe District People's Hospital for bronchial asthma and emphysema.After being admitted to the hospital, it was the first-level nursing. At 0:30 on the 15th, the old man had an asthma attack. The family members who were taking care of him rushed to find the doctor on duty, but the other party said that the medicine had already been used, and we had no choice. What kind of medicine did you take at home? ?The family members said that they took compound theophylline when they were sick at home.The doctor said: "Then let's give the patient this medicine." After only 2 oral medicines were given, no one supervised him.During this period, the staff on duty did not inspect and nurse the patient as required, causing the patient's asthma to last for as long as 6 hours.When Wang Guimei, Shen's seventy-year-old wife next year, approached the on-duty doctor Chen and the nurse Zhang several times to ask for emergency measures for the patient, but Chen looked at the patient casually and said, "I have used the medicine just now, why don't you take the medicine?" What do you want us to do?" Then he left.When the family members of the patients approached them several times, they were either sleeping in the duty room, or there was no one at all.Because Shen Ming's condition was not controlled in time, the condition worsened. From 6:00 in the morning, the patient passed a large amount of tarry stools, and soon fell into a coma and shock state.All these doctors and nurses on duty were completely unaware, and said: We thought the patient had slept through the night... After repeated urging by the family members, the doctor on duty came in a hurry. At about 6 o'clock in the morning on the 15th, the patient's condition deteriorated; due to the lack of timely rescue, at 22:30 that night, the patient convulsed again, his face was blue, and his life was dying. On the morning of the 16th, the hospital decided to intubate her trachea and put her on a ventilator.Unexpectedly, after the ventilator was installed, several people didn't know where to start, only heard the alarm kept ringing.When the family members asked the reason strangely, the other party replied: "This machine looks like this, you just press it for a long time..." The alarm did not disappear until the next afternoon when the ventilator stopped.What made the family even more puzzled and angry was that when the hospital was using the ventilator, from the deputy director in charge to the chief and deputy director of internal medicine, the attending physician, the head nurse, and all the nurses present, none of them knew how to use the ventilator correctly!However, because they did not know how to operate, the endotracheal tube was blocked, which further deteriorated the patient's condition and eventually caused the patient's death.Even later, it was not the hospital that took the initiative to remove the ventilator, but the family members of the patient found that the patient was in critical condition and specially called an anesthesiologist for emergency treatment.Even when the patient was in an extremely dangerous state, the doctor on duty did not observe and record the patient's condition at all. It is still unknown who was on duty at that time, let alone take any effective measures.

After only 11 days in the hospital, the old father died in the hospital he created!Shen Shuping, the daughter of Shen Ming, who used to be the head nurse of Beidaihe District People's Hospital, works in a branch hospital more than ten kilometers away from the general hospital. She happened to be on duty in the branch hospital when her father was hospitalized. Nursing, and when she left, she specifically asked the nurses and doctors to patrol the patients as required and take care of them carefully.She thought that the leaders of the hospital would definitely pay attention to her father's condition, but she didn't expect that her father, who was not seriously ill, would die in her own hospital!

The sudden death of the old father plunged the Shen family into great grief.At this time, Wang Guimei, an old man who had been with her husband for more than 50 years, was the one who suffered the biggest blow. She had been guarding his bedside since his husband fell ill and was hospitalized. How did my wife die.The old mother once asked Shen Shuping if the hospital gave the wrong medicine?If it weren't for the indifference and a series of faults of the relevant personnel in the hospital, and with his wife's strong body, it would be impossible for him to leave her so soon.As soon as his wife died, the 70-year-old woman immediately fell ill on the bed, crying and grieving all day long, suffering from myocardial infarction and has not healed yet!Her father died, and her old mother fell ill again. As the only daughter of her parents, Shen Shuping had to ask for leave to take care of her mother at home.Shen Shuping, who was 47 years old at the time and had worked in the hospital for 32 years, knew very well that her father's death was not unrelated to a series of mistakes in the hospital's treatment process.

In order to thoroughly understand the real situation of her father's treatment at that time, Shen Shuping took advantage of the convenience of her work in the hospital and managed to obtain the original records at that time after the incident and made copies.When they wanted to review the special care records after their conflicts with the hospital intensified, Shen discovered a cruel fact that stunned her: the hospital had completely changed the original special care records!According to Shen, "During the treatment of his father, the internal medicine department of Beidaihe Hospital had severely incomplete records of the course of the disease. Sometimes the medicines were given without doctor's orders. Seriously violated the relevant rules and regulations formulated by the Ministry of Health..."

Shen Shuping believed that her father's death was caused by the chaotic management of the hospital's leaders, who only focused on politics, neglected business, and had an indifferent attitude. What made Shen Shuping's family even more chilling was yet to come. After the unfortunate death of her father, although Shen Shuping was deeply saddened, but considering that her father was the founder and old leader of the hospital, and she is now a medical staff who has worked here for 32 years, she really did not want to have a relationship with the hospital unless it was absolutely necessary. Besides, she still has feelings for her hospital, she just hopes that they can learn lessons, improve their work, and better serve the elderly in their hometown, so that similar situations will never happen to other patients.In the end, after discussion between her and her family, they no longer pursued the responsibility of the relevant personnel, nor asked the hospital to compensate for this, but only asked the relevant personnel at that time to come to the door to apologize.

Unexpectedly, what they didn't expect was that such a request, which was not too much, was indifferently rejected by the leaders of the hospital.Not only did they ignore it, Li Xingguo, the vice president in charge, even said indifferently, "It is not normal for a patient to die at such an age and serious condition...Shen Shuping, what the hell are you doing? ".When Shen went to director Sun Shuying to explain her intentions, the other party's attitude was even worse. She was thrown out of the house immediately, and she was accused of looking for trouble and ruining the good reputation of the hospital.

Shen Shuping showed me a thick stack of materials. Among them, the "Schematic Diagram of the Cause of Death of the Patient" was an in-depth and detailed investigation of the circumstances leading to the patient's death with relevant experts and attorneys from the Beijing Medical Dispute Professional Committee. After the investigation, it took more than a month to draw it together. At the same time, she also showed me many strong evidences that can prove that the hospital had illegal operations and medication errors in the process of treating her father. Shen Shuping, who was in tears, said angrily: "My father's illness at the time was completely curable, but he died at the hands of these people in the end! If it is an ordinary consumer, it is impossible for them to know what is happening during the rescue process. What happened in the hospital, let alone the relevant facts hidden in it; if I was not a medical staff who is proficient in medical knowledge, I would have no way of knowing their illegal operations and indiscriminate medication at that time; if I was not in this hospital After working for 32 years, it is impossible for me to get the medical records at that time, and it is even more impossible for me to find out that the hospital has blatantly changed them after the incident, falsified them, and attempted to cover up the facts. Therefore, ordinary people It is really difficult to win a medical lawsuit! As a special patient, my father is not only the old leader of Beidaihe Hospital, but also one of the main founders of the hospital, and I am also a person who has worked in the hospital for a long time. 32 years, and served as a senior nurse for more than ten years. Employees like us who have a dual relationship with the hospital, the relevant responsible persons of the hospital are so irresponsible, with such a bad attitude and indifference, let alone mediocre consumers... In addition to seeking justice for my father, at the same time, more importantly, as an old employee of the hospital, I just want to use the fact that my father was put to death, just want to use my The most authentic evidence I have investigated and obtained is used to operate on my own hospital. I just want the people of the world to see what the current state of Beidaihe Hospital is like."

The dead are long gone.As a family member, I didn't expect that now I can't even get a verbal apology from the hospital!After waiting for more than a month, Shen Shuping, who has been working in the hospital for 32 years and has always been kind to others, was so sad and indignant that she couldn't bear it anymore and decided to use the law to seek justice for her late father. They decided to sue the hospital. court.However, if you want to fight this medical lawsuit, you must first apply to the local health department for a medical appraisal.Angrily sue Shen Shuping who works in the hospital

On July 7, 2001, when Shen Shuping was doing a medical appraisal at the Beidaihe District Health Bureau, she unexpectedly discovered that the person in charge of the medical appraisal was actually a relative of the main person in charge of Beidaihe Hospital!The dean of this court, Li Xingguo, is actually one of the members of the appraisal team. On November 6, 2000, Beidaihe District Medical Malpractice Appraisal Committee believed that "the patient Shen Ming's diagnosis was correct during hospitalization, the treatment principles were reasonable, and the drug treatment and various treatment measures were appropriate. Although the hospital had actively rescued and treated", the patient died of pulmonary encephalopathy , Gastrointestinal bleeding and other multiple organ failures lead to cardiac arrest and death.Although the hospital had incomplete records in its work, it was not the cause of the patient's death, and there was no other fault during the treatment process. " and made an appraisal conclusion that "this incident does not constitute a medical accident". Faced with such an appraisal, the Shen family naturally refused to accept it, and immediately applied to the Qinhuangdao City Medical Accident Technical Appraisal Committee for medical appraisal. On July 20, 2001, Qinhuangdao City The Medical Malpractice Technical Appraisal Committee issued a notice to the family of the deceased that "does not constitute a medical malpractice", but the other party admitted in this notice: "Beidaihe Hospital does have deficiencies in the process of treating and rescuing patients and recording medical records..." Faced with this contradictory appraisal, the Shen family hurriedly applied to the relevant provincial department for a new medical appraisal. At the same time, they decided to first file a lawsuit with the People's Court for medical damage compensation.

In June 2001, five plaintiffs, Wang Guimei, wife of the deceased, eldest son Shen Yongping, daughter Shen Shuping, second son Shen Jianjian, and third son Shen Liping, put Beidaihe District People's Hospital on the grounds of disputes over medical damages and asked the court to order The defendant compensated a total of 267,185 yuan for nursing expenses, hospital food subsidies, child support, funeral expenses, appraisal fees and other economic losses and mental damages, and required the defendant to bear all litigation costs. On July 8, 2002, the Beidaihe District People's Court heard the case of Shen Shuping and other plaintiffs suing Beidaihe Hospital for the first time. At around 9 a.m. on October 8, 2002, I came to the People's Court of Beidaihe District along with seven or eight reporters from Workers' Daily, Health Times, Democracy and the Legal System, and the Legal Column of Shanghai TV Station. Participated in the second hearing of the case.More than ten minutes before the trial, we went to the office in charge of publicity of the court to explain our purpose, and when we showed the relevant certificates and letters of introduction, unexpectedly, a young man on the other side said: "Who told you reporters to come? Our court has no Please come here! I can't control this matter, you go to the leader." We had to split up to find the leader of the hospital.I searched almost all the offices, but I didn't see a leader.Seeing that we had seven or eight journalists and a TV station, one of the female staff members quietly pointed out to me: "Our president has gone to a meeting. You'd better go directly to the president of the civil division." When we found In the office of the chief civil judge on the first floor, after carefully checking our documents, the other party said with a straight face: "This matter should have been specially approved by the leadership of the court..." Although the other party's attitude was not very friendly, after all, he had already asked for permission. We entered the court to attend the hearing, and we quickly agreed.Unexpectedly, just as we journalists were about to enter the court, something unexpected happened. We heard several representatives of the defendant Fang Beidaihe Hospital shout at us: "Where are you from? What do you want to bring here with the TV station? Then, a few more people ran from inside and yelled fiercely at Xiao Tang, the editor-director of Shanghai TV Station, and Xiao Shi, the cameraman: "No entry! Anyone who dares to enter will be beaten!" In a blink of an eye, several strong The big man rushed over and pushed Xiao Shi, who was holding the microphone and the camera on his shoulder, straight away.Two of them also ran over to snatch the camera."Workers' Daily" political and legal reporter Zhou Xingwang and I yelled angrily: "We are journalists, and we all have the right to report. You are not allowed to treat reporters like this!" The president of the judge shouted: "Didn't we just get your permission, why did we treat the reporter like this?" Unexpectedly, the other party and a judge shouted at us angrily: "Recording and filming are not allowed, and TV stations are not allowed to come in! Get out! Come out, let me out!" Seeing this situation, we had no choice but to ask the two colleagues from Shanghai TV station not to go in for the time being.Seeing that the other party was so nasty, the young and vigorous videographer Xiao Shi took a few shots at the other party, which made them even more angry. Under the order of the judge, two bailiffs came up to snatch the camera. At the same time, several people from Beidaihe The people in the hospital surrounded him aggressively.Zhou Xingwang and I hurriedly protected the two and retreated to the gate, and the other party gave up. At about 11:30 in the morning, the trial ended.I don't know whether it was because the plaintiff and the defendant argued too hard, or because so many journalists were present, the court adjourned for the second time.Seeing that the trial was over, several of our news organizations decided to interview relevant leaders of the Beidaihe Court on related matters after discussion, and asked the court to explain everything that happened before the trial.We came to the court office, found three staff members, two men and one woman, and asked to find the leader of the court.The other party asked us to find it by ourselves, and we held back our anger and said: "We have searched all the offices on the first and second floors, but we couldn't find anyone, so we asked your comrades in charge of propaganda..." Before I finished speaking, one of them Young men in plain clothes rushed us out impatiently.The other party's arrogance and rudeness had already angered us, and Zhang Hui, a female reporter from "Democracy and the Rule of Law", and I immediately asked: "Who are you? What is your attitude? Are you from the court? Please show your relevant information. Documents?” The other party glanced at us dismissively: “Am I the court’s none of your business?” Zhou Xingwang and I accused angrily: “If you can’t produce the relevant documents, then please shut up immediately! You don't have the right to treat us journalists like this!" Whether he knew he was wrong or saw Xiao Shi pointing the camera at him, this gentleman hurriedly turned his head away, and under the persuasion of the other two people, he hurried away. The next day, I, Xiao Tang and Xiao Shi went to Beidaihe Hospital to interview related matters, and the "courteous treatment" we received was even more dumbfounding. Because we had experienced the arrogance of the people in the court and the hospital as early as the day before, Xiao Tang and Xiao Shi must have asked me to go to the hospital together.Before that, I had been to Beidaihe Hospital several times, but nobody paid any attention to me, so I had to find out some information by phone.This time, I especially want to have a direct confrontation with the relevant leaders of the hospital.In order to prevent accidents during the interview, the kind-hearted Shen Shuping also specially asked her friend Xiao Zheng to bring a local young man to "escort" behind us. At about 9:00 in the morning, we first went to the entrance of the hospital to secretly take a few shots, avoided the security guards, and took three steps from the gate to the outpatient hall of Beidaihe People's Hospital.As soon as we entered, the three of us immediately separated according to the interview plan. As soon as Xiao Shi entered, he carried the camera around to rush to shoot, while Xiao Tang and I interviewed Xing, the director of the internal medicine department who had appeared in the court as an agent of the hospital.Unexpectedly, as soon as we entered, we immediately aroused the vigilance of the relevant personnel in the hospital.When Xiao Tang and I rushed to the door of the internal medicine department, we saw him using his mobile phone to report our arrival to the hospital leader.The interview was naturally rejected by the other party.Seeing that the other party's attitude was still so indifferent, we knew that many unfavorable situations would happen at any time, so we made a quick decision and quickly rushed up the stairs on the left side of the hall, and then quickly jumped into the elevator to rush to the office of the hospital leader. The three of us and the two "bodyguards" who followed us went straight to the dean's office on the fifth floor, but there was no one there; we went to the adjacent "Hospital Party Committee Office". Although the door was open, But it was also empty.Seeing this, we had no choice but to look for the publicity department of the hospital, but found that the publicity department and the security department of the hospital had the same sign.After knocking on the door, there was only one typist looking around. After hearing our explanation, the other party said in a panic: "Oh, you are so fast, your reporters have already arrived here. Our leaders will go down to find you It's..." Four or five minutes later, a short, fat man in uniform ran over, followed by several security guards looking around.Probably running too fast, the man named Li Hongfu pushed open the door, panted heavily, and shouted at us, "Where are you from? Who sent you here? We didn't get our consent." What are you doing here in the hospital?" I introduced myself calmly, and Xiao Tang and Xiao Shi took the initiative to show their IDs.When we proposed that we came here specially to meet the hospital leader, the other party said with a long face: "Our hospital leader is busier than the central leader, please tell me what you have." Then he ordered us to quickly show the press card; She carefully looked at our relevant documents, and asked the female typist to take them outside to copy them. Seeing our strong protest, she actually asked two security guards standing outside the door to guard us.Under my firm request, this talent is not allowed to send people to go to the leadership of the academy.Just as the proud chief of the security section and director of the Propaganda Department was questioning us, a thin-faced middle-aged man wearing gold-rimmed glasses walked in.Although I have seen him in court yesterday, I don't know his name yet.After repeated questioning by me, he reluctantly told us that he was Zhu Xinxin, the deputy secretary of the hospital's party committee. The deputy secretary said: Our hospital is run by the Communist Party, and it serves the local people wholeheartedly. Our place is very good, and there has never been any problem. As for the matter of Shen Shuping's father, it is Shen Shuping who is looking for trouble. Well, she is deliberately making trouble with the leaders of our hospital... We are not afraid of her going to court with us.When asked about disputes, he either answered irrelevant questions or avoided answering them.Finally, the well-mannered deputy secretary of the party committee pointed to our noses and said: "Our hospital likes to be interviewed by reporters..." When we repeatedly asked to interview the dean and secretary of the party committee, the other party replied, "I went to a meeting. ,not at home……" Baby boy's "womb shows no abnormalities" While I was investigating the case of Shen Shuping suing Beidaihe Hospital, I received another complaint about the death of a four-month-old baby boy because the hospital illegally used an intern without medical qualifications to practice medicine. . The complainant is a young couple who live in Beidaihe District. The woman's name is Huang Mei, and her husband's name is Liu Yong.It is understood that at about 5 o'clock in the morning on February 28, 2002, Huang Mei and his wife found that their son Liu Binyue, who was only 4 months old, suddenly had a fever and diarrhea, so they rushed to the nearby Beidaihe District People's Hospital to see the emergency department.The doctor on duty, Mr. Wei, did not do any examination, just looked at the child, and diagnosed, "Don't worry, the child is fine, it's just viral enteritis." Then he prescribed medicine and gave the child an injection, and then Just wave them home. At around 7 o'clock that night, they found that the child's fever continued to rise, and they returned to the hospital with the child in their arms, only to find that Wei was still on duty at this time.Wei also claimed that he was on duty for someone else.Knowing that the child still had diarrhea and the body temperature reached 38c° and other abnormal conditions, he still said "nothing happened" and gave the child an infusion without measuring the body temperature or conducting blood and urine routine tests and other biochemical indicators. Soon after infusion of the second bottle of liquid, Huang Mei and his wife found that the child had fever all over the body, straight eyes, bruises around the eyes and the center of the person, and sunken eye sockets. They were so frightened that they hurriedly looked for the doctor on duty, who was sleeping in the duty room. Wei Mou just handed out a thermometer from the crack of the door for them to measure the child by themselves, saying that it might be caused by the too cold inside.Huang Mei and his wife insisted that the child was absolutely abnormal, and asked if it was caused by the transfusion.Then Wei turned around and glanced at the infusion bottle, with a panicked expression on his face, then he suddenly and quickly pulled out the needle, and then said to them in a disguised manner: "The child's infusion is too cold, and the room is too cold. Let's go home to warm up first." His evasive demeanor aroused the suspicion of Huang Mei and his wife, so they repeatedly asked him what kind of liquid he had infused just now.Wei said it was nothing, just said "it's all tonic, it doesn't get in the way".But they kept insisting that something was wrong with the child and asked to find another doctor to examine the child.Wei said impatiently: "It's so late, who do you tell me to go to? I can guarantee that your child is fine..." At about 6 o'clock the next morning, Huang Mei and his wife held the child dubiously as soon as they entered the door, they found that the child's face was flushed, his eyes turned white, and his breathing became weaker and weaker. They were so frightened that they hugged the child and went there The hospital rushed and went straight to the emergency room.At this time, Wei became flustered, overwhelmed with fright, and hurriedly looked for help.Although the hospital took some first aid measures for the child, it failed to save the child's life in the end... Afterwards, they learned that Wei was just a trainee who had just graduated, and he had no qualifications to practice medicine at all, let alone the right to prescribe independently. Yesterday, he was allowed to sit in the emergency department alone at night because of insufficient staff in the hospital... In order to calm things down, the hospital induced them to sign for many times without issuing a death notice, agreeing to the autopsy within 48 hours, and rejected the family members' repeated requests to participate in the autopsy process. While waiting for the identification report, the Beidaihe District Health Bureau and the relevant leaders of the People's Hospital admitted that the hospital was responsible and promised to deal with the matter fairly; Things go wrong.Two days before the report came out, Sun Shuying, the legal representative and director of Beidaihe Hospital, also plausibly stated at the staff meeting and public places of the hospital: "The child's death has nothing to do with us, he choked to death while feeding..." It was not until 20 days later that the hospital issued an autopsy report full of loopholes, concluding that "acute respiratory failure caused by inhalational asphyxia". I saw that the "autopsy report" that was examined on March 14, 2002 was stamped with the big red seal of the Pathology Department of Qinhuangdao First Hospital.It was in this four-page report that there were two autopsy conclusions: acute respiratory failure caused by inhalation asphyxia and viral enteritis.On the third page of the report, I suddenly found such a conclusion: "Pelvic examination - no abnormalities were found in the bladder." "No abnormalities were found in the double appendages of the uterus"? ! For the extremely strict appraisal procedure of the autopsy report, why did the dignified Beidaihe Hospital make such an incredible mistake?Could it be that the leaders of the local health bureaus and hospitals involved in the identification didn't understand that the deceased was a 4-month-old male baby? ! When I interviewed the Party Committee Office and Hospital Office of Beidaihe Hospital on the phone about this aggressive and strange incident, the other party immediately hung up the phone as soon as they heard that it was a reporter's interview. Later, Huang Mei and his wife came to Beijing with all the information and found relevant experts. According to the medicine used and the child's symptoms, the child's death was caused by poisoning shock and respiratory failure due to drug allergy. Although some experts have made an authoritative analysis, facing the reality, the hospital and local management still ignore it. On March 22, 2002, the Medical Malpractice Technical Appraisal Committee of Qinhuangdao City ignored the statements of the family members of the deceased at all, and finally made a conclusion that "it does not constitute a medical malpractice". After many consultations with lawyers and relevant legal experts, Huang Mei and his wife believed that Wei, an intern doctor at the Beidaihe District People's Hospital, was conducting diagnosis, treatment and nursing of small patients without medical qualifications, which seriously violated the regulations. Prescribing indiscriminately; when the child was found to be abnormal, instead of taking emergency treatment measures, he coaxed the family members and evaded responsibility, so that the rescue time was delayed, resulting in the serious consequences of the child's death. The conditions for constituting medical accidents stipulated in the explanation of several issues in the Handling Measures are also in line with the responsibility for major medical accidents, which constitutes a crime. We should request the public security organs to investigate Wei's criminal responsibility in accordance with the provisions of Article 335 of my country's "Criminal Law"; During the autopsy, the staff of the autopsy and relevant personnel of Beidaihe Hospital deliberately did not conduct blood tests, intending to fabricate false facts to help Wei avoid legal investigation; Ignoring the appraisal and still accepting the autopsy report and making an appraisal conclusion that violates facts and science also clearly violates the provisions of Article 305 of my country's "Criminal Law" and can be investigated for criminal responsibility.At the same time, the family members can also request the public security organs to re-conduct pathological examination and blood analysis on the body of the deceased Liu Binyue to find out the real cause of death. Subsequently, Liu Yong and Huang Mei's couple immediately reported the case to the Beidaihe District Public Security Bureau on the grounds that Wei was practicing medicine illegally.The police immediately opened a case and investigated it.But on June 28, 2002, the branch office showed the couple a notice to withdraw the case. Afterwards, a person in charge of the sub-bureau said with emotion to the reporters who came to interview the matter: In fact, the behavior of the intern doctor constituted the crime of illegal medical practice, but due to the hospital's activities around and other reasons that are inconvenient to speak, they had no choice but to act according to the law. The relevant documents of the higher authorities make such a decision. Seeing that the police had withdrawn the case, the helpless Huangmei and his wife had no choice but to file a civil lawsuit. But when they came to the Beidaihe Court to file the case, the president of the court told him clearly: We have a lot of medical accidents here. Let me tell you the truth. Beidaihe Hospital cannot be sued, so it is best not to file a lawsuit. The criminal case that the police had originally filed for investigation has now been withdrawn. If they wanted to take the hospital to court on the grounds of medical disputes but the court refused to file the case, this civil lawsuit would not be successful.The couple had to hug each other and cry. At the same time, the relevant person in charge of Beidaihe Hospital and the leaders of the Health Bureau worked hard to do the work of Huang Mei and his wife, and pointed out that as long as they agreed not to file a lawsuit, the hospital could pay RMB 150,000 in one lump sum.The desperate Huangmei couple had no choice but to accept the advice of various people, and finally accepted the one-time compensation from the hospital against their will with sad tears.