Chapter 2 2. The indictment of life

There is only one life, and it is precious to everyone.And life is so fragile, it is not a candle that can be ignited again after being blown out, but porcelain that cannot be restored after being broken. Therefore, some people say that medical staff are porcelain porters, and there should be no mistakes. Do all our medical staff feel this way?The reality gave us an unoptimistic answer: many lives were "shattered" by the indifference and carelessness of the medical staff... One day in September 1991, Qi Yao, a female student from a college of traditional Chinese medicine in a certain city, was sent to a central hospital for treatment after being scalded by boiling water.During the intravenous rehydration, Qi Yao vomited and had difficulty breathing.Her father reported it to the doctor, and the doctor said: "I have already handed over my shift, so I will talk to the doctor on duty." His father went to the doctor on duty, and the answer was: "It doesn't matter." The doctor and the nurse who were chatting said: "There is no doctor this weekend." On the third morning, Qi Yao scratched her throat and kicked her legs, struggling desperately. Air leak.The patient in the next bed took off his own oxygen bottle and gave it to her. More than 10 minutes later, a doctor brought the equipment to prepare for intubation, squeezed the ball a few times, muttered "Why is there an air leak", and left the ward.

Qi Yao gestured helplessly in the air with both hands, trying to grasp the last hope of life, but was lost forever.A young girl who was in her cardamom years ended her life in this modern hospital just by scalding her skin with boiling water... The patient's life is despised and trampled by the angel in white whom we rely on the most. We don't know whether this is the misfortune of the patient or the sorrow of the angel in white? ! A deputy company commander who fought on the forward position of Mount Faka even complained angrily: "Is this just a medical accident? What about human nature, conscience, and morality? A death report can be ignored. But I lost four relatives in vain, my family was ruined, how sad!... I never thought that we were bleeding and sacrificing in the front, but our wife in the back was looked down upon by the hospital. What is the conscience of these people? Such an incident happened , It was entirely caused by the negligence of the obstetrics and gynecology department. I am sad, I escaped the enemy's guns on the front line; but in the rear, my wife died at the hands of my own people!..."

The tragedy happened on June 10, 1988. His wife, Chen Jian, who was 8 months pregnant with a third child in a factory in Zhuzhou City, Hunan Province, walked into the hospital accompanied by her mother. Her feet were severely edematous and her blood pressure was high, so she wanted to be hospitalized for observation.But the doctor neither checked nor inquired about her condition, so she was sent home with a high-risk pregnancy. On June 12, Chen Jian went to the hospital again under the urging of doctors at the hypertension survey station. On the 26th, Chen Jian had a dry cough and difficulty breathing. He wanted to have an examination, but the doctor said, "It's twins. Mao Mao is compressing the blood vessels. It doesn't matter."

In this way, Chen Jian's symptoms worsened day by day, his abdomen was swollen and shiny, and he was tortured. His relatives asked for a caesarean section, but the doctor said, "If you are less than 37 weeks old, you can't have a caesarean section. What do you know?" In fact, it has been 37 weeks and two days since July 2. On the evening of July 3, the hospital administered oxytocin without discussing with the family members and dragged down three baby boys with a uterine aspirator. The three baby boys died at the scene. The tragedy continues to unfold.Due to multiple births, Chen Jian bled too much after giving birth, his face was pale, and his blood pressure was abnormal. The doctor seemed to realize the seriousness of the problem, but he needed a blood transfusion, no!Blood type, I don't know!They took the blood to record the bill, but they couldn't find it in the messy drawers... They asked their relatives to take the money, and went to the city at 12 o'clock in the evening to buy two bottles of blood.However, the blood they had worked so hard to buy was not transfused in time, and it was delayed until the next day.

On July 11, Chen Jian finally died of severe postpartum sepsis and a series of complications due to lax disinfection of induced labor, sloppy operation, and failure to actively prevent infection before delivery. How can such a hospital feel safe? I really don't understand, where is the morality and conscience of the "angels" who save lives and heal the wounded?When the relatives of the patient asked about the condition, they were blamed; when rescuing the patient, the doctor came out of the ward and shouted: "Who is the escort? The doctor is resuscitating. Why don't you buy some cold drinks, soda or ice cream!" Chen Jian The mother had no choice but to abandon her dying daughter, borrowed money and hastily asked someone to buy more than 40 sticks of ice cream, 2 catties of cake, and more than 100 bottles of soda.

How is this not chilling? The soldier defended the motherland, but no one came to protect his wife and children! What scares us the most is not cancer, not AIDS, not cholera, smallpox, or plague, but the chaotic management of hospitals, the indifference and dereliction of duty of medical staff! The French philosopher Montaigne pointed out: "Among all the shortcomings we have, the most rude is to despise our existence." Medical malpractice is the greatest tragedy that despises our existence! The "Liaoning Daily" reported on October 3, 1992: On July 6, 1991, Jiang Fengqin, a 44-year-old resident of the East Railway Station Committee of Baita District, Liaoyang City, went to the Liaoyang City Emergency Center for a severe headache and had a CT scan. An exception was found.

On July 7, Jiang Fengqin was transferred to the fourth ward of Liaoyang Central Hospital. On July 8, the hospital performed a "lumbar puncture" on Jiang Fengqin, but no cause was found. On the afternoon of July 9, Jiang Fengqin's condition worsened, and she passed out at about 15:00. At 16:00, Jiang Yuehui, Jiang Fengqin's younger brother, found Director Xie Youyi of the Fourth Internal Medicine Department, and Xie gave Jiang Fengqin a 250ml bottle of mannitol. Xie called one of the vice presidents. The vice president said that he had a client and asked him to seek emergency consultation with the director of internal medicine, Liu Hangao. Is it that urgent? What's wrong? I'll go back later." Xie didn't wait for the consulting doctor to arrive, so he left the patient alone and went home for dinner.

When it was 18 o'clock, Xu Hong, the successor doctor, checked Jiang Fengqin and said she was fine. Jiang Yuehui said, "My sister has passed out, so give me some medicine!" Jiang Yuehui stomped his feet anxiously. He went to Dr. Xu again half an hour later, and got the same answer as before.After waiting for another 10 minutes, Jiang Yuehui went to ask again. At this time, Xu Hong called Liu Hangao's family to urge him. Liu was about to eat at that time. Near 19 o'clock, Director Liu, who was late for emergency consultation for more than two hours, finished the examination of Jiang Fengqin. Said: "Normal, not sick!" After that, I went to chat with Xu Hong in the doctor's duty room.Jiang Yuehui went to the duty room and asked: "Director Liu, is my sister's coma a disease?" Liu said: "Go back and see if your sister wets the bed?" It’s not a disease, it’s not bed-wetting.” “Is it okay to have an enhanced CT?” “No need, your sister’s CT is normal, you can go back, it’s fine.”

At about 22:00, Jiang Fengqin became more difficult to breathe, a bit like snoring, and wet the bed again.Jiang Yuehui pushed the door into the doctor's duty room and said earnestly: "Director Liu, my sister wets the bed again, go and have a look!" At this time Xu Hong said: "What's so good about bedwetting! You can't believe that you will go to another hospital Go, you still don’t believe what the chief expert told you.” Liu Ye said, “It’s okay, I’ll have it checked tomorrow.” Jiang Yuehui returned to his sister’s side and fidgeted, seeing her face turning purple like a dead person, panting and snoring .

At 23:40, Liu Hangao walked out of the duty room.Jiang Yuehui stepped forward and grabbed his arm and begged: "Uncle! You can go into the house and have a look. My sister is heavier than before, and I'm not in a good mood." "No, the car to take me home is waiting outside. Go!" At this time, Liu Hangao was only four or five steps away from Jiang Fengqin's ward, but he said: "You need to find Dr. Xu." Around 3 am on the 10th, Jiang Yuehui knocked on Dr. Xu's door again.Xu asked: "Does your sister usually snore in sleep?" I touched my nose again.

At 5:20 a.m. on the 10th, Jiang Fengqin's brother and sister rushed over, and Jiang Fengqin's face was as ugly as death.Jiang Yuehui tried it under her nose with his hand, and he was out of breath! "I can't, my sister is dying, help me!" Jiang Yuehui cried and ran to Dr. Xu.At this time, the nurse came over, she pinched Jiang Fengqin's eyelids and then walked back.After a while, the doctor Xu Hong came, but he didn't bring a stethoscope.When she took out the stethoscope and put it on Jiang Fengqin's body, she was dumbfounded and started artificial respiration, sweating all over her face from nervousness.Jiang Yuehui reminded: "Hurry up, use the first-aid medicine!" Xu then said several kinds of medicines to be given by the nurse, and then went to the third internal department to borrow an oxygen cylinder. After more than ten minutes, the oxygen cylinder was not installed yet. , Xu Hong said to the family members: "Blow into your mouth, pinch your nose, and give artificial respiration." Then, Xu Hong returned to the doctor's duty room and was busy writing the medical progress record. At 6 am on the 10th, Jiang Fengqin passed away forever. This is an investigation by a reporter from Liaoning Daily.What is intriguing is that the Liaoyang City Health Bureau made four medical appraisals on this issue. The first three times did not come up with any conclusions. The last time Jiang Fengqin, who died after being in a coma for 13 hours, was described as "sudden death". general medical malpractice".Liaoyang Central Hospital believed that it was not even an accident. Although Jiang Fengqin's treatment and rescue were ineffective, the fourth internal department did its duty, and some deficiencies in the diagnosis and treatment work had no direct relationship with Jiang Fengqin's death. Is it the responsibility of medical staff to be indifferent to patients and indifferent to the development of the disease?The 13-hour coma is called sudden death, and the failure to observe the patient's condition and deal with the patient in time is called "technical-based medical malpractice".Anyone with a conscience who knows the above inside story will feel heartbroken. ——The Red Cross is bleeding, our hearts are bleeding! It is precisely because of ineffective investigations and even cover-ups by relevant departments that medical accidents frequently occur in China. "China Prosecutor's Daily" reported on October 2, 1992: Doctors Kang Longhui and Li Pengfei of the People's Hospital of Xinzhou District, Shanxi Province, played mahjong and gambled while on night shift, causing the condition of the 12-year-old patient Zhang Lei to deteriorate, and the timing of treatment was delayed and he died. First-level medical liability accident. On the evening of July 31, 1992, Zhang Lei, a primary school student in Xinzhou City, was admitted to the hospital because of adhesive intestinal obstruction. The attending doctor Kang Longhui gave him conventional treatment.The next day, a vice president of the hospital instructed that if the patient was not relieved after 48 hours of systematic conservative treatment, an operation would be required, but Kang was indifferent and did not implement it. On August 4, the patient's abdominal fluoroscopy revealed obvious surgical indications, but Kang still did not take measures, and lost the best time for surgery. At about 10 am on August 5, Kang Cai performed the operation on Zhang Lei at the request of the patient's family many times.But now 100 hours have passed, and the operation was more than 70 hours late.Diagnosed after operation: adhesive intestinal infarction, ileal diverticulitis perforation. At 10:40 that night, the patient after the operation suddenly fell into a coma and convulsions.Kang was called in, some therapy was given and things improved.At 12 o'clock in the middle of the night, Zhang began to convulse again, and his blood pressure dropped rapidly. The patient's father hurried to find Kang again, and Kang Zheng and the doctor on duty, Li Pengfei, were playing mahjong and gambling in the duty room.The patient was in a critical condition. After his father and the nurse on duty found out, they called Kang five times in a row. Kang was still obsessed with the gambling table, so he only gave the nurse a verbal doctor's order: give him 500cc of glucose... It wasn't until 4 o'clock in the morning of the next day, after the mahjong game ended, that Kang was called out by the nurse to see the patient, but no emergency measures were taken, and the doctor on duty, Li Pengfei, never left the room.Zhang Lei's condition continued to deteriorate. On the morning of the 6th, in view of the deterioration of Zhang Lei's condition, the hospital consulted Zhang Lei.At this time, he had symptoms such as toxic shock, toxic encephalopathy, myocarditis, and multiple organ failure. On the 7th, Zhang Lei, who had been in a coma, was getting bigger and bigger, and more and more pus and feces-like liquid flowed out from the drainage tube. On the morning of the 8th, Zhang Lei suffered from kidney failure again. In the early morning of the 9th, Xiao Zhang Lei, who was dying, was operated on for the second time by the hospital. At 5:50 am on the 10th, Xiao Zhang Lei, who had been on the death line for 10 days, finally stopped breathing.The boy's life was ruined in the hands of Kang Longhui, who had seriously neglected his duties. Playing cards and gambling is already a violation of discipline, but for ordinary people, it may only corrupt the social atmosphere and disrupt social order. For medical staff who are tasked with saving lives and healing the wounded, taking off work to gamble during working hours is tantamount to putting patients to death , is to kill life directly. The 71-year-old Gong Hongliang was also cruelly killed by a doctor who went to work to gamble. At 5:00 pm on March 14, 1998, Wang Tao, a surgeon at Shangrao County Hospital in Jiangxi Province, went to work at the hospital.After taking over, Wang asked a few people to play mahjong at his colleagues' home.At about 1 o'clock in the middle of the night, the patient Gong Hongliang was escorted by his family to the emergency room for treatment.The nurse on duty immediately called Wang Tao back to examine the patient and was diagnosed with appendicitis.After Wang wrote the doctor's order, he called the nurse for something, then left the ward and returned to his colleague's house to continue playing. One hour later, the patient was in unbearable pain and was sweating profusely. Seeing that the situation was not good, the family members called Wang to check.Wang promised to go there later, but he never put down the mahjong in his hand. At about 6 a.m. the next day, the patient had difficulty breathing. Nurses and family members went to invite Wang Tao three times in a row.It was not until 7:15 that Wang returned to the surgical ward, but the patient Gong Hongliang could no longer be rescued. Appraised by the Shangrao County Medical Liability Accident Appraisal Committee, the cause of death of the patient was diffuse peritonitis caused by perforation of acute appendicitis complicated by toxic shock and acute adult respiratory distress.As a doctor on duty, Wang Tao left his post to gamble, and failed to observe and deal with the changes in the patient's condition in time, which delayed the timing of rescue. This case is a first-level medical liability accident.The court of Shangrao County, Jiangxi Province sentenced Wang Tao, the attending surgeon of the county hospital, to one year in prison for the crime of medical malpractice. If it is said that Kang Longhui and Wang Tao ruined two lives through their dereliction of duty, Zhengzhou Fourth People's Hospital lost their mother forever to a pair of twin boys who came to the world for 18 hours due to the carelessness of individual medical staff. "Forensic Medicine World" reported in the fifth issue of 1996 that Yang Jizhen, a female worker of a welding branch factory in Zhengzhou, was admitted to the Obstetrics and Gynecology Department of Zhengzhou "Four Medicine" because she was about to give birth. twins.When Yang was pushed out of the delivery room with the joy of postpartum, she was very tired and said to her worried husband Wang Jian, "I'm fine, I'm just a little hungry." Wang then ordered a special meal for maternity. After lunch, Wang Jian advised her to rest , she said she couldn't sleep, and excitedly talked to the visiting workers for a while.At 3:00 p.m., Yang Jizhen was inserted with a urinary catheter due to difficulty urinating, and soon began to bleed. Wang Jian went to the nurse, and the nurse said "it's okay" and left.More than ten minutes later, the bleeding increased, and Wang Jian went to the nurse to report it. The nurse said impatiently: "Bleeding is normal after giving birth. Don't make a fuss. You won't rub her?" Wang Jian rubbed his wife's abdomen as instructed by the doctor. Blood continued to flow out. At 5:40, a doctor came and suddenly asked Yang Jizhen, "Do you remember the three pieces of gauze during delivery, have you taken them out yet?" Yang said, "I don't know." The doctor then left in a hurry. At 8:30 p.m., there was more bleeding and blood clots flowed out. Wang Jian was very disturbed and went to call the nurse again. The nurse went to the delivery room to rub and squeeze the mother's abdomen again, and then a large amount of blood and blood clots gushed out. was washed away.At the same time, the nurse gave Yang two injections, saying that it was a drug to help the uterus contract, and asked Wang Jian to continue pushing and rubbing the abdomen for the pregnant woman. At this time, Wang Jian was already afraid, and asked timidly, "Is it okay?" The nurse replied, "It's okay, it's all like this." After the nurse left, Yang Jizhen wanted to urinate, but she couldn't urinate when she sat on the bedpan. The blood that flowed into the bedpan was four to five centimeters deep. At about 10 o'clock in the evening, Yang Jizhen sat on the bedpan for the second time, and the blood flowed in the basin. Wang Jian went to call the nurse again in horror... just like that, calling and asking, "Is there something wrong?" "It's all right" replied, but the blood of the mother Yang Jizhen had soaked the mattress, and there was half a basket of toilet paper soaked, but a doctor never appeared. At 00:17, under Wang Jian's repeated urging and pleading, the careless nurse hung up two bottles of liquid for Yang. At about 1:00, Yang started to bleed again, and Wang Jian called out to the nurse again in horror, followed by several nurses and doctors. A young nurse put on rubber gloves and took out four or five egg-sized blood clots from the parturient. An experienced nurse reached out and fumbled a few more times, but nothing else came out. They decided to operate and pushed the parturient into the delivery room.About 40 minutes later, Yang Jizhen was pushed out, her limbs were cold, her face was pale, and she could only hum. A few minutes later, a nurse brought a bottle of blood plasma. During the blood transfusion and needle injection, the parturient suddenly twisted and screamed: "My back is sore, my back is sore..." The cry gradually faded, and then it seemed to be snoring. Wang Jian thought that his wife had died after the operation. The condition improved, fell asleep, and didn't care. At 3:30, he found his wife was still sleeping, feeling out of sorts, and rushed to the duty room crazily, shouting, "Doctor, come quickly, hurry up, please save her!" Wang Jian shouted Kneeling on the ground, paralyzed all over, he was reprimanded by a fat nurse: "Having a baby is a matter of life and death, and I don't know who will die on it! What are you talking about!" It was at this time that they felt the seriousness of the problem, but they were unable to recover. No matter how they pressed the woman's abdomen, it was useless. When Wang Jian and his family came, Yang Jizhen's heart had stopped beating. The hospital bed soaked in blood held Yang Jizhen and her eyes that could not be closed until she died, telling the world her grief and indignation at being delayed in treatment... The patient's life is largely in the hands of the doctor.If they are serious and responsible, the patient will have hope of life; if they neglect their duties, the patient will be in danger of death.From this point of view, doctors hold the power of life and death of patients. Liu Yuan is a senior high school student in a certain city. He is 17 years old and has a height of 1.81 meters.In school, he was excellent in character and learning, and liked sports. He also won the men's 100-meter silver medal in the city middle school student sports meeting.At home, he is the only child, the darling of his parents, the jewel in their palm.His only minor complaint was that his tonsils were constantly inflamed.The college entrance examination is about to take place. In order to avoid trouble during the college entrance examination, the parents decided to use the summer vacation to have their children have their tonsils removed. They came to this big hospital in the city.The doctor on duty that day is Dr. Ouyang, a young and beautiful female doctor.Liu Yong's parents never dreamed that after they entrusted their son to this beautiful female doctor, the shadow of death began to hang over their son's head. The beautiful Dr. Ouyang likes to dance the most, and there happened to be a dance that she thought she had to attend that night.So, from going to work in the morning, she has been a little restless: she needs to wear a new style of clothes, and her hair needs a new hairstyle.So, she called a doctor who was studying in another hospital, and told him confidently that today's tonsillectomy was arranged for him.Doctors in training are naturally willing to have this kind of training opportunity, but they are worried that their skills are not up to standard.Doctor Ouyang encouraged him and said, "Hey, a small tonsil, I trust you!" Indeed, in today's highly developed medicine, for a specialist doctor, removing the tonsils is really not complicated. The patient does not need to lie down, but just sit or half-recumbent. Use vascular forceps to split the tonsil capsule up and down, align the wire ring with the root and twist it, and press the cotton ball for a while, and it's done!The movements are quick and the whole operation takes less than 10 minutes. According to regulations, changing doctors before surgery requires a report for approval, and doctors who are in training need to ask Corey for instructions before going to the operating table.However, Dr. Ouyang disregarded all the rules for the evening dance party: "Don't ask, I will be responsible." After reaching an agreement in private, Dr. Ouyang walked briskly towards the Xinchao hairdressing salon. At this time, in the corridor of the hospital, Liu Yuan and his parents were led by a nurse, talking and laughing. operating room... After finishing his hair, Dr. Ouyang returned to the department excitedly, and was immediately disappointed. Xiao Liu, who had just finished the operation, vomited blood in the ward. to the savior. Xiao Liu was sent to the operating room for the second time. This time, Dr. Ouyang still did not report to the superior as required, and the abnormal phenomenon of the patient did not attract her due attention.After the patient returned to the ward, his face was pale, his body was weak, and he continued to vomit blood. Maybe I have seen a lot in the hospital, and I am not surprised. The little pain of the patient vomiting blood has not aroused Dr. Ouyang's sense of responsibility and sympathy.At noon, she went home without leaving any doctor's orders. At this time, Liu Yuan was vomiting blood profusely. His mother had taken most of the jar, but he was still vomiting and rubbed his stomach with his hands constantly, excruciating pain.He couldn't speak anymore, he just gestured with his hands to tell his mother that the blood seemed to be still flowing in his stomach. "Doctor, please, can you transfuse the child with some blood?" Liu Yuan's mother asked Dr. Ouyang who came back from dinner. "You're in a hurry, it's okay, there's no need." Doctor Ouyang flatly refused. Xiao Liu's mother continued to beg hard, as if she already had a premonition that something bad would happen.In order to get rid of the entanglement, Doctor Ouyang had no choice but to show mercy: "It's okay, let's lose." After 400ml of plasma was injected into Liu Yuan's blood vessels, his complexion seemed to improve slightly.However, a doctor who is a little more careful and responsible will find that the patient's physical signs have undergone some terrible and obvious changes.But Dr. Ouyang no longer has the mind to pay attention to these changes. At this moment, what lingers in her heart is tonight's dance. She told the student doctor that she had to do something urgent.Dr. Jinxiu had noticed some changes in the patient, and he expressed his worries to Dr. Ouyang.But Dr. Ouyang still said confidently: "This is often the case in tonsil surgery. It's okay. I'll be back in a while." After finishing speaking, he left. This "moment" is more than 3 hours.During these more than 3 hours, she danced in the ballroom with skillful steps, while Liu Yuan struggled in pain. Liu Yuan fell into a coma and started to have a fever.The training doctor was in a hurry and was at a loss. Doctor Ouyang returned to the hospital reluctantly after dancing the last dance.At this time, Liu Yuan had a high fever of 39.5 degrees.The factory doctor invited by Liu Yuan's mother introduced the abnormal situation of the patient for several hours to Dr. Ouyang. Dr. Ouyang interrupted impatiently: "Got it, I have eyes. This is not a small clinic in your factory. I also You don't need to teach me." At this time, the bright red plasma in Xiao Liu's mouth sprayed out, and he fell into a coma again.Dr. Ouyang thought he was unlucky to meet such a difficult patient today.She ordered Liu Yuan's father: "Take him to the treatment room." Liu Yuan's father couldn't help going over and asking, "How do you get there?" "You carry it on your back." Doctor Ouyang said. Liu Yuan's father couldn't believe his ears. According to his thinking, the child was so sick that it was best not to carry it casually. The doctor should rescue him on the hospital bed. If necessary, he should push it on a flat cart. However, in the hospital, who dares to say "no" to the doctor?No matter what the doctor said is right or wrong, you can't offend him. In the treatment room, Liu Yuan's father had this conversation with Dr. Ouyang: Liu Yuan's father said, "Doctor, can you give the child some fluid?" Dr. Ouyang said: "The liquid supplement is enough, no need." He said, "Can I get some blood?" After vomiting so much blood, as a doctor, of course she knew that she should make up more, but she also had her reasons: "Where do you go to get blood in the middle of the night?" After doing some simple treatment, Dr. Ouyang went back to the lounge to sleep.After a while, Liu Yuan's father saw that Liu Yuan's condition had worsened, so he had no choice but to knock on the door: "Doctor, the child keeps rubbing his belly and can't breathe. I'm afraid something will happen. Please go and have a look." He also said timidly as if he had committed some serious crime: "I'm really sorry to disturb your rest!" "You don't need to look at it. Tonsil cutters often do this. I haven't seen you doing so much. Let's talk about it tomorrow morning." Seeing the child in great pain on the hospital bed, the father begged again, hoping to move this indifferent doctor. "I said tomorrow will be tomorrow." Doctor Ouyang became angry, "Let's go, I'm going to close the door!" Xiao Liu's father was angry, he really wanted to scold her and beat her up, even if he went to jail for it!However, he thought of the dying child, he swallowed his anger, and with a "plop", he knelt down in front of the doctor. Yue'er hid in the clouds, as if she couldn't bear to watch this sad scene; Night Breeze was sobbing in grief, as if mourning for this helpless father... Doctor Ouyang moved his jade toe anyway, and came to the ward.She took one look at the patient—just one look, no pulse signal, no auscultation, and no medical order for the nurse. She only left a sentence: "It's okay!" She was like a judge of life, and the sound of the hammer As soon as it fell, he left leisurely.Liu Yuan's last chance to return to life was lost forever. Dr. Ouyang was right. When she returned to sleep, Liu Yuan, the young man who was alive and kicking the day before, was "all right"—he closed his eyes, stopped his heartbeat, and a strand of grievances rushed to the sky... Is this the hospital we depend on?Is this the angel in white we respect and trust?We shudder! After Han Xiaomei became pregnant, thinking of the baby to be born, she even laughed out loud in her dreams.However, no one would have imagined that on the day the child was born, Han Xiaomei's young life came to an end. This year, she was only 28 years old. According to the "China Youth Daily" report, at 2:40 pm on November 3, 1997, Han Xiaomei, a resident of Jiyuan City, Henan Province, was full of the joy of being a mother and was escorted to the Jiyuan City Family Planning Guidance Station (hereinafter referred to as the Family Planning Station) to wait for delivery.After admission examination, Han Xiaomei's body temperature, blood pressure, respiration, pulse, heart and lungs were all normal, and the results of gynecological examination were also normal. Only the B-ultrasound examination revealed slow uterine contractions. At 4:00 p.m., the doctor gave Han Xiaomei an intravenous drip of oxytocin. At 6:00 p.m., Han Xiaomei felt chills and flustered. The doctor on duty was called to check the situation, but did not take any measures.At 7 o'clock in the evening, another doctor from the family planning station went to the ward to understand the condition, and took Han Xiaomei's temperature, but did not take any measures.At 8 o'clock in the evening, Han Xiaomei still felt chest tightness and chills. The hospital sent Han Xiaomei to the delivery room without taking other measures. Soon, Han Xiaomei gave birth to a baby boy. At 9:20, after the medical staff left, they did not go to the bedside of the parturient for nursing care.Han Xiaomei felt chills and flustered all the time. Her family members asked the doctor, but the doctor said: "The mother is cold, so you can give her something to eat and drink." Around 9:50, Han Xiaomei suddenly went into shock, and the doctor was arrested Call for rescue.Because the mother needed a blood transfusion, Han Xiaomei's family immediately went to the Jiyuan City Blood Bank to get the plasma. After the plasma was taken at 10:30, there was no staff on duty in the laboratory of the family planning station. This is the blood cross test. At 11:20, the doctor told Han Xiaomei's family members that the mother may have amniotic fluid embolism, and there is only a 1% chance of saving it. If the hysterectomy is performed, there is still hope. Otherwise, there is no hope at all.The family members agreed to the operation and signed it. The operation was carried out in the ward. What is surprising is that the facilities of the family planning station are so simple. The surgical instruments are not sterilized, so the doctor pours some alcohol and ignites them for disinfection; There is no rack, so the family members have to stand on the windowsill and hold the liquid bottle. At 11:45, the doctor asked the family members to go to the blood bank to get back two more packs of blood. Of the four packs of blood taken back and forth, only a little more than one pack was transfused, and the blood could no longer drip into the patient's body.After the uterus was taken out, the mother suffered from respiratory and circulatory failure, and Han Xiaomei died at 0:40 am on November 4. Han Xiaomei left in such a hurry, she couldn't take another look at her 10-month-old little life. Han Xiaomei's death brought great grief and anger to her relatives. Her husband almost had a nervous breakdown, and her parents and in-laws became sick with grief.In order to take care of the infant who was waiting to be fed, her parents reluctantly cut down the fruit trees, and her parents-in-law gritted their teeth and gave up the contracted greenhouse vegetable field... In order to seek justice for the deceased, Han Xiaomei's family members submitted an accident appraisal to the Medical Malpractice Appraisal Committee of Jiyuan City Apply. Due to Han Xiaomei's premature burial, the Medical Malpractice Appraisal Committee failed to obtain the autopsy certification materials. According to the investigation, the appraisal opinion was: the family planning station used oxytocin without clear indications for the parturient, and the dosage exceeded the conventional dose, and it was not strict enough. Observation of the labor process and recording of the drip rate led to amniotic fluid embolism in the parturient. At 18 o'clock, the parturient felt chills and flustered, which was an early manifestation of amniotic fluid embolism. Measures, resulting in further deterioration of amniotic fluid embolism, 23:00, it was too late to take measures after diagnosis of amniotic fluid embolism.The various situations of the patients after admission all indicate that the internal management system of the family planning station is not perfect, and there is still a big gap in undertaking the rescue work of critically ill puerpera.The appraisal conclusion was a medical technology accident of the first grade. The Family Planning Station had objections to the fact identification part of the appraisal, but agreed with the conclusion.The family of the deceased believed that it should be defined as a medical liability accident, but the higher authorities refused to accept the application for re-evaluation. In desperation, Han Xiaomei's relatives sued to the Jiyuan City Court, and they wanted to seek justice through the law. On the morning of February 24, 1998, the civil court of Jiyuan City Court heard the case.The court held that: Han Xiaomei was in the normal labor process when she was admitted to the defendant’s place, and the defendant overdosed oxytocin without indications, causing Han Xiaomei to experience amniotic fluid embolism, and the defendant did not take measures within nearly two hours, causing Han Xiaomei His condition deteriorated further, and he died after rescue efforts failed.The Medical Accident Appraisal Committee of Jiyuan City appraised that Han Xiaomei's death was a first-class medical technical accident.According to the provisions of Article 106, Paragraph 2 and Article 119 of the General Principles of the Civil Law of the People's Republic of China, the court made a first-instance judgment, ordering the defendant family planning guidance station to compensate the plaintiff for medical expenses, transportation and accommodation expenses, nursing expenses, funeral expenses, mental health expenses, etc. The loss, child support, education expenses and other items totaled more than 130,000 yuan. Life, for everyone, is only once, how can we be so indifferent, so contemptuous? The blasphemy of life is the most heinous of all crimes!