Q: What prompted you to study the history of Muad'di in this way? A: Why do I have to answer your question? Q: Because I'm going to save your words. Answer: Aha!Absolutely fascinating for a historian! Q: So, are you willing to cooperate? A: Why not?But you'll never understand where my historical analysis was inspired.will never.You priests have too many scruples lest... Q: Give me a chance. A: You?This, then again...why not?I was mesmerized by the unassuming, unobtrusive appearance of this planet, as everyone calls it: the dunes.Mind you, it's not Arrakis, it's the dunes.The history of the dunes is fascinating both because of its desertity and because it is the birthplace of the Fremen people.Previous historical research has mainly focused on local customs.These customs stem from the scarcity of water and the semi-nomadic lifestyle of the Fremen.The men wore a type of distillation suit that recycles most of the water that the body emits.

Questioner: Are these not facts? A: Facts on the surface, but ignore what lies beneath the surface.It's tantamount to... trying to understand the planet I was born on, Ix IX, just by the name, but not where it came from: it's the ninth planet in my solar system.no no.The dunes cannot simply be seen as stormy places, and the problem is not just the threat posed by giant sandworms. Q: But for people who live in Araken, these things are the most critical! Answer: The key?certainly.But these things made the planet's scenery single and unchanging, and Dune itself became a planet with only one crop, that is, spices.It is the only place where spices and spice mixtures are produced.

Q: That's right.Let's hear what you have to say about divine spices. Answer: Holy?Spices, like all sacred things, are given with one hand and taken back with the other.It can prolong life, and veterans can also rely on it to predict the future.But it can also make you a drug addict, marked by eyes like yours: all blue with no whites.Your eyes, your organs of vision, become one without contrast, appearing as nothing but blue. Questioner: It is these heresies that brought you into this cell! Answer: It was you priests who brought me into this cell.You too, like all the other priests, learned early on to call the truth heresy.

Q: You have been brought here because you have the audacity to say that Paul Atreides lost something crucial to his humanity in order to become Muad'di. A: Yeah, he didn't lose his father in the Harkonnen War, and Duncan Idaho didn't sacrifice his life so Paul and Lady Jessica could escape. Q: Your cynicism will be on the record. Answer: Cynical!Of course, this charge is more serious than heresy.But you know, I'm not really a cynic, just an observer, a commentator.I saw real nobility in Paul when he fled the desert with his pregnant mother.Naturally, she was both a great asset and a burden.

Q: One of the things that annoys you historians is that you don't let a little flaw go.You see nobility in Muhammad al-Muad'dib and you have to put a cynical footnote on it.No wonder the Bee Geist sisters have similarly denounced you. Answer: You priests did a good job bringing up the Bee Geist Sisterhood as an excuse.But the reason why they can survive to this day is also because they concealed what they did.But there was one fact they couldn't hide: Mrs. Jessica was a master trained by Bee Geist and had trained her son in Bee Geist's way.My sin is to study this as a phenomenon, and to elaborate on the psychics and genetics that Muad'd-Dib received from them.You do not wish to draw attention to the fact that Muad'di was first and foremost the Savior the Sisterhood had long sought and wished to take into their own hands, their Kwizaki Hadnaj and then your Prophet.

Q: If there was any last hesitation about your death sentence, you have now completely removed it. A: Too bad I can only die once. Q: There is one way of death and one way of death. Answer: You have to be careful, don't let me accidentally become a martyr.I don't think Muad'di would... tell me Muad'di knew what you were doing in these dungeons? Q: We don't bother the Holy Family with these trivial matters. A: (Laughs) Paul Atreides fought so hard to become a Fremenian shrine figure, and this is how he ended up!Learning to control and control sandworms, is this what it is for?I really shouldn't be answering your question.

Q: But I will still keep my word and keep your words. A: Really?Then listen carefully, you degenerate Fremen, this priest who has no other gods in his eyes except himself!There are so many things you don't understand.It was a Fremenian ritual that caused Paul to first take a large dose of the spice mixture, thereby initiating his prophetic visions.The same religious ritual of the Fremen, and also because of the spices, awakened the unborn Alia in Lady Jessica's womb.The baby Alia, born into the world, possesses full-fledged consciousness, all the memories and knowledge of the mother.Do you know what that means to her?Worse than the ravages of rape.

Q: Muad'di could not have been the leader of the Fremen without the holy spice.Aria cannot be Alia without a divine experience. A: You wouldn't be a priest without the blind tyranny of the Fremen.Haha, I understand you Freemen.You consider Muad'di as one of your own because he shared the bed with Ghani and adopted Freeman customs.But he was an Atreides first and foremost, and had been trained by a master Bee Geist.You don't understand his cultivation at all.You think he has brought a new organization with a new mission.He also promises to you that he will turn this wild and dry planet into a paradise of blue waves.He confuses you with such illusions, he robs you of your innocence!

Q: Your heresy doesn't change the fact that ecological change is taking place at a rapid pace on the dunes. A: My heresy is to dig out the root of the change and study its consequences.The battle that took place on the plains of Araken may prove to the world that the Fremen were able to defeat Sadukkah's army.But what else could it mean?The interstellar empire of the Corino family has become the Freeman Empire under the rule of Muad'di, other than that, what has changed?Your jihad took only twelve years, but what a lesson it taught us.Now the subjects of the empire finally understood the nature of the false marriage between Muad'di and Princess Irulan.

Q: How dare you accuse Muad'di of hypocrisy! Answer: You can kill me, but I am not talking nonsense.The princess is just his consort, not a companion.Jani, his tiny Freeman lover, was his true companion.This is a well-known fact.Yirulan is just a key for him to ascend the throne, nothing more. Q: No wonder all those plotting against Muad'di use your historical analysis as a reason! A: I can't convince you, I know that.But prior to my historical analysis, conspiracy and rebellion were still justified.Hadi's twelve-year jihad is the justification.It was it that brought about the coalition of the ancient power classes and sparked the rebellion against Muad'di.